Hutchinson has played in 19 NJCAA Tournaments. This is a list of Blue Dragon Men's Basketball players who earned spots on the NJCAA Tournament All-Tournament teams.
1949 – Leroy Esau
1957 – Charles Reynolds
1959 – Dick Gisel
1960 – Bill French
1961 – John Channell
1966 – Mike Jones
1968 – Russell Clarke
1970 – Stan Blackmon
1971 – Stan Blackmon
1972 – Richard Morsden
1973 – Rudy Jackson; Teko Wynder
1975 – Randy Boyts
1986 – Tyrone Jones; Derrick Vick
1988 – William Davis; Steve Fritz; Maurice Brittian (MVP)
1994 – Roy “Pooh” Hairston (MVP); Ben Davis; Lucas Wagler
1997 – Ryan Moss
2016 – Bashir Ahmed; Keanu Pinder; Akbar Hoffman
2017 – Shakur Juiston (MVP; Samajae Haynes-Jones; J.J. Rhymes
2017 – Angelo Stuart