2023
Will Edmunson – Arkansas
Ben Dandelet – Illinois State
Reed Scott – Nebraska-Omaha
Kaden Wickersham – Washington State

2022
Hunter Gotreaux – Nichols State
Konnor Kirchhoffner – North Dakota State
Ben McLaughlin – Arkansas
Ryan Schlotzhauer – Incarnate Word
Sterling Sutcliffe – Incarnate Word
Jack Torosian – Creighton
Jack Whitlock – Iowa
Cade Baker – Nebraska-Omaha

2021
Austin Callahan – Nebraska-Omaha
Mason Lowe – Oklahoma
Tyler Delong – Austin Peay
Cade Fenton – Central Arkansas
Will Reetz – Nebraska-Omaha
Drew Reetz – Nebraska-Omaha

2020
Luke Sartori – Nebraska
LJ McDonough – Wichita State
Dawson Linder – Louisiana Monroe
Chris Noble – Louisiana Monroe
Cody Farmer – Texas State

2019
Jake Bunz - Nebraska
Matt Delcambre – New Orleans
Riley Metzger – Oklahoma State
Dylan Nedved – Iowa
Logan Sartori – Texas A&M
Zane Schmidt – Texas A&M
Zach Philbin – Nebraska-Omaha
Miguel Reyes Jr. – New Mexico

2018
Bobby Morgensen – Florida Atlantic
Wyatt Divis – Texas-Arlington
Crit Williams – Central Oklahoma
Dayden Lane – Stephen F. Austin
Masen Palmier – Southeast Missouri State
Garrett Stephens – Southeast Missouri State
Julian Rip – South Carolina-Upstate
Scott Wolverton – Morehead State

2017
Nolan Hoffman – Texas A&M
Michael Hellman – Texas A&M
Caden Doga - Tulane
Nolan Hakel – Nebraska

2016
Jake Bublitz – Morehead State
Kyle Cantu – Morehead State
Cole Donaldson – Southern Mississippi
Bobby Milacki – Grand Canyon
Lucas Milner – Kansas State
Josh Williams – Delta State

2015
Andres Castillo - Grambling State
Quintin Crandall – Kansas State
D.J. Gasso – Bradley
Brock Hammit – High Point
Josh Kunzmann – South Dakota State
Billy Lovvorn – Oral Roberts
Chris Pinne – Texas Pan-American
Max Simpson – Oklahoma State
Alex Stuart – Stephen F. Austin
Jordan White – Grambling State

2014
Jake Ek – Northern Colorado
Austin Harms – Northern Colorado
Reed Morton – Washburn
Tanner Raiburn – Grambling State
Jake Schleppenbach – Nebraska
Kyle Simonds – Texas A&M
Dakota Shadoan – University of San Francisco

2013
Christian Cox – Nebraska
Brooks DeBord – Kansas State
B.B. Kimbrel – Wichita State
Logan Landon – Texas Pan-American
Josh Markel – Central Arkansas

2012
Toby Cornejo – Northwestern State
Grant Dunnegan – UNC-Charlotte
Jace James – Missouri
Tanner Lubach – Nebraska

2011
Morgan Cirbo – Murray State
Tyler Klouser – McNeese State
Jory Goldstrom – New Mexico State
Joey Goodwin – Kansas State
Connor McClain – Indiana State
Andrew Urban – Creighton

2010
Luke Acosta – Oregon State
Paul Anderson – Nicholls State
Jamell Cervantez – Cincinnati
Andrew Dixon – Purdue
Shaun Hoover – Northwestern State
Dan Klein – Kansas State
Mace Krol – Nicholls State
Shawn Lewick – Kansas State

2009
Trever Adams – Creighton
Clay Cuno - Creighton
Scott Keffer – Arkansas-Little Rock
Adam Roy – Northwestern State
Tim Statz – Mississippi State

2008
Eric DeBlanc – Northwestern State
Ben Ferrell – Indiana State
Matt Yerby – Northwestern State

2007
Scott Heitshusen – Michigan State
Logan Hoch – Wichita State
Kori Jensen – Bradley
Aaron Pribanic – Nebraska
Jonathan Yerby – Central Arkansas

2006
Andrew Dirks – Wichita State
Clint Elkins –Niagara
Brandon Doherty – Michigan State
Austin Presley – Kansas State
Chris Rusler – Jacksonville
Thad Weber – Nebraska

2005
Jason Banks – Northern Colorado
Noah Krol – Wichita State University
Andrew Prignitz – Northern Iowa
Torey Williams – Centenary

2004
Kevin Dryanski – Arizona State
Brian Hastings – University of Kentucky
Alex Kringen – UNLV
Mike Lynch – Drexel
Gus Milner – University of Kansas
Bryan Peterson – Kansas State
Dayton Reis – New Mexico State
Adam Schroeder – St. Louis University

2003
Seth Brown – Creighton
Micah Cornett, Kansas
Wes Hartley – Oklahoma
Jon Hunton – Lamar
Truan Mehl –Maryland
Josh O’Dell – Texas
Kyle Tebow – New Mexico State
Mike Zagurski –Kansas

2002
Frank Bauer – Kansas State
Brad Flanders – Missouri
Brandon Johnson – Kansas
Matt Rebout – Murray State

2001
Josh Condon – Texas-Arlington
Brent Cramer – Arkansas State
Tony Daniels – Creighton
Blake Denischuk – Arkansas State
Ryan Finan – Lamar
Eli Lapka – Arkansas State
Shaun Menke – Texas-Arlington
Derek Roper – Missouri

2000
Kent Becker – Wichita State
Aaron Marsden – Nebraska
Josh Peterson – College of Charleston
Matt Rackers –College of Charleston
Craig Reed –Northwestern State
Dustin Whipple – Oklahoma State

1999
T.J. Bohn – Iowa State
Eric Hammer – Western Kentucky
J.J. Korf – McNeese State
Cory Metzler – Texas Tech
Tim Olson – Florida
Ryan Spaney – Texas A&M-Corpus Christi
Hershell Stoner – Louisiana-Monroe

1998
Nolan Parker – McNeese State
Jordan Robison –Northwestern State

1997
Eric Bettis – Kansas
Chris Finnegan –Southern Mississippi
Jody Harris – Missouri
Rob Holmes – Creighton
A.J. Seaholm – Texas Pan-American
Scott Stover – Arkansas State
Justin Valasek – Nebraska

1996
Josh Bailey – Kansas
Mike Haley – Missouri
Jonny Mitchell – Missouri
Christian Sterling – Creighton
Jim Voisin – Centenary

1995
Carlos Akins – Western Kentucky
Brook Court – Kansas State
Chris Hesse – Southern Mississippi
Adam Hust – Oral Roberts
Chris Lewis – Oral Roberts
Matt Podjenski – Missouri
RO Riley – New Mexico State

1994
Andy Balzer – Xavier
Josh Bradford – Xavier
Jack Witt – Kansas State

1993
Bob Courter – Nebraska
Marc Manwarren – University of New Mexico

1992
Joe Cromer – Western Kentucky
Neil Farthing – Kansas
Matt McKay – Nebraska
Dale Wicks – Oklahoma State

1991
Rick Croushore – James Madison
Chad Huebner – Creighton
Pat McLeod – Wyoming
Vic Salazar – Southwest Texas State